Comparative Statistics and Timelines of
Japanese and British COVID-19 Responses
Statistical Comparisons of COVID-19 in Japan and the UK
The four graphs below are taken from the University of Oxford and Global Change Data Lab’s Our World in Data project. They contain depictions of COVID-19 related statistics for Japan and the UK. While both countries have seen increasing rates of deaths, cases, and testing over the past nine months, the UK has experienced a much steeper rise in both deaths and cases. Even when one takes into account the higher testing rate in the UK, the gradual rise in confirmed COVID-19 cases in Great Britain has increased at a rate much higher than Japan’s.
Comparative Timelines of COVID-19 Responses in Japan and the UK
UK
WHO confirms detection of novel coronavirus
The World Health Organization (WHO) confirms the detection of a novel coronavirus. On 30 January, the WHO declares a global public health emergency.
UK confirms its first COVID-19 case
UK confirms its first COVID-19 case. On 3 March, the UK government releases its Coronavirus Action Plan. The initial response resists any mandatory measures, keeping schools, restaurants, theatres, clubs, and sporting venues open, and advising only the over-70s and those with flu-like symptoms to self-isolate for 7 days. Johnson and other members of the government recommend washing hands as the primary way to avoid catching COVID, although on 3 March he mentions shaking hands with everyone in a ward treating COVID-19 patients. Later advice recommends social distancing particularly for vulnerable groups, and advises against non-essential travel. National borders are kept open – a decision later criticised for enabling the virus to be continuously imported into the UK. Large sporting events continue to be held into March, including the Cheltenham races and football matches, according to the rationale provided by members of SPI-B (the behavioural science subcommittee of Sage) that people would go to pubs to watch sport or socialise instead, leading to an even greater risk of viral transmission. This approach changes with the Premier League decision to suspend games on 13 March. A series of large critical care “Nightingale” hospitals is planned to deal with the expected influx of COVID patients, although as of November these are largely unused despite their cost of over £200m.
COVID-19 Related Policy Action throughout February is minimal
During February, little policy action is taken related to COVID-19, as the Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies (SAGE) and its subcommittees formulate advice and recommendations based on evidence emerging from Asia and Europe. Prime Minister Boris Johnson is criticised for not attending emergency meetings of the COBRA (Cabinet Office Briefing Rooms) committee to discuss the crisis until 2 March. Cases in the UK continue to rise steadily. However, the first British COVID-related death takes place in Japan, on board the Diamond Princess cruise ship on 28 February.
Herd Immunity and “Behavioural Fatigue”
Government scientists initially seem to advise an approach of building up herd immunity in the population, while Chief Medical Officer for England, Chris Whitty, cites the possibility of “behavioural fatigue” on 9 March as a reason for delaying a national lockdown, arguing that if imposed too early, people might tire of following the rules. Yet “behavioural fatigue” has no basis in behavioural science, and it is unclear where the idea originates from: the behavioural subcommittee advising Sage (SPI-B) deny they suggested it, as does the government’s “nudge unit” (the Behavioural Insights Team). On March 12, Public Health England stops testing members of the general population with COVID symptoms and manually tracing their contacts due to the scale of transmission.
Hospitals send older adults back to care homes
An Imperial College London research group led by Prof Neil Ferguson (a member of SPI-M, the modelling subcommittee advising Sage) predicts that the current virus mitigation strategy would lead to 250,000 deaths, and recommends a suppression strategy instead. This has an immediate impact in shifting expectations around the need for more stringent measures to avoid travel and social contact, which Johnson announces on the same day. At this point, modellers estimate around 100,000 new infections are taking place each day. On 17 March, members of SPI-M realise that the rate at which the virus is doubling is faster than previously thought. This data is fed to Sage, leading to greater pressure for a national lockdown before NHS capacity is overwhelmed. On the same day, NHS England and NHS Improvement write to hospital trusts telling them to “expand critical care capacity to the maximum” by freeing up beds in order to be able to cope with the expected influx of COVID patients. Older adults begin to be discharged back into care homes, with no requirement to being tested for COVID until rules are changed in mid-April. Health Secretary Matt Hancock’s claim in mid-May of having thrown a “protective ring” around care homes belies the primary focus on freeing up capacity in the NHS. Up to October, 20,000 care homes residents out of a total population of 400,000 will die of COVID, as modellers and ministers fail to realise that the use of agency care staff means that care homes cannot be “cocooned” from the community. On 6 July, Johnson blames care staff for the infections: “too many care homes didn’t really follow the procedures in the way that they could have.”
Prime Minister delivers TV broadcast instructing a lockdown (stay-at-home order)
In a televised address, Johnson announces a nationwide lockdown lasting at least 3 weeks, and introduces the slogan: “Stay home, protect the NHS, save lives”. Shortly afterwards, Johnson falls ill with the virus and Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab takes over amid uncertainty about who is in charge of national decision-making. Government spokespeople appear on TV alongside the UK’s chief scientific advisors to provide daily updates on the state of the pandemic. During lockdown, police in England issue approximately16,000 fines for alleged breaches of the restrictions. The lockdown is finally lifted in stages from mid-May. Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland begin to take their own measures for extending or easing lockdowns and introducing other restrictions and slogans.
COVID Symptom Study App is launched
The COVID Symptom Study app is launched as a not-for-profit initiative by health science company ZOE, with scientific analysis provided by King’s College London. The app is downloaded 4 million times by October 2020, and is awarded a £2 million grant by the Department for Health and Social Care. Data collected by the app identifies new COVID-19 symptoms, including loss of smell and skin rashes, and provides insight into “long COVID”. Health Secretary Matt Hancock announces a scheme to recruit 250,000 volunteers to support people shielding at home. Over the next 24 hours, 500,000 people sign up, a number that eventually rises to 750,000. Johnson calls this response a sign of “incredible public spirit.” But the majority of these volunteers are never assigned any task, leaving many frustrated. Throughout March and April, tens of thousands join grassroots local mutual aid groups that spring up and communicate via WhatsApp and Facebook groups.
5-pillar plan for testing announced
Health Secretary Matt Hancock announces a 5–pillar plan for testing with a target of 100,000 tests per day by the end of April. In order to meet this highly ambitious timeframe, the government decides not to build up existing NHS hospital, university, or Public Health England testing capacity. Instead, it begins to put together a complex new testing system dominated by the private sector, with tests checked by a variety of “Lighthouse” laboratories run by corporations. Test capacity increases, but there is criticism that the official figures on testing are misleading, as they include even test kits put in the post that may not be completed or returned.
5G conspiracy theories during COVID-19
Three mobile phone masts in England are set on fire by conspiracy theorists who claim a link between 5G and COVID-19.
Google and Apple to assist with functioning of decentralised Bluetooth contact-tracing apps
Google and Apple announce the development of a system to help the development of decentralised Bluetooth contact-tracing apps. Two days later, Health Minister Matt Hancock announces the development of a “new NHS app for contact tracing”, led by NHSX, involving a centralised system where contact history data is stored on a central NHSX server rather than on a person’s own device, and that will also rely on users inputting their symptoms rather than positive test results. Head of NHSX Matthew Gould tells parliament’s science and technology committee that a centralised approach offers “profound benefits” for tracking the virus and suggests that waiting for the Apple/Google framework would slow development down. However, Google and Apple will not allow a new app that hasn’t been developed through their framework to use Bluetooth running in the background, meaning that any attempt to build an app that uses this functionality will be largely ineffective. In addition, an open letter published on 19 April and signed by hundreds of professors from 26 countries warns that contact-tracing apps could if they become a tool for “large scale data collection on the population”. The government’s ethics advisory board, set up to oversee the development of the digital contact tracing app, writes to Hancock warning that unreliable contact-tracing apps could provide a false sense of security and worsen the spread of COVID-19. On 20 April, Ada Lovelace Institute publishes “COVID-19 Rapid Evidence Review: Exit through the App Store?” which argues that the current “technical limitations” and “social impacts” outweigh the potential benefits of the government’s proposed app. On 6 May, the Financial Times reports that the UK government has hired a Swiss software developer to build a second app, this time using Apple and Google’s decentralised system. The first app is tested on the Isle of Wight at the start of May – a decision criticised as unrepresentative of England and Wales’ populations at large. “catastrophically hamper trust” if they become a tool for “large scale data collection on the population”. The government’s Ethics Advisory Board, set up to oversee the development of the digital contact tracing app, writes to Hancock warning that unreliable contact-tracing apps could provide a false sense of security and worsen the spread of COVID-19. On 20 April, Ada Lovelace Institute publishes “COVID-19 Rapid Evidence Review: Exit through the App Store?” which argues that the current “technical limitations” and “social impacts” outweigh the potential benefits of the government’s proposed app. Meanwhile, the UK parliament’s Joint Committee on Human Rights states that the government’s privacy assurances are not sufficient to protect data privacy and propose new legislation to ensure it, including the creation of a Digital Contact Tracing Human Rights Commissioner. On 6 May, the Financial Times reports that the UK government has hired a Swiss software developer to build a second app, this time using Apple and Google’s decentralised system. The first app is tested on the Isle of Wight at the start of May – a decision criticised as unrepresentative of England and Wales’ populations at large.
Independent Sage is formed
Independent Sage, a shadow version of the government’s Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies (Sage), is formed amid concerns about “dangerous” political interference in official advice to the government following reports that government adviser Dominic Cummings had attended some Sage meetings. The group is led by Sir David King, a former government chief scientific adviser, who states: “I am not at all critical of the scientists who are putting advice before the Government … but because there is no transparency, the government can say they are following scientific advice but we don’t know that they are.”
Professor Neil Ferguson resigns as a government advisor
Influential epidemiologist Prof Neil Ferguson resigns as a government advisor after it is revealed that he broke lockdown rules. He is the latest in a series of influential figures who break lockdown or social distancing rules, which will eventually include UK senior government aide Dominic Cummings, Scotland’s chief medical officer Dr Catherine Calderwood, Scottish National Party MP Margaret Ferrier, ex-leader of the opposition Jeremy Corbyn, Johnson’s father Stanley Johnson, and others.
UK’s public health messaging changes
The UK’s public health messaging changes, as the previous slogan, “Stay at home. Protect the NHS. Save lives.” is replaced on 11 May with “Stay alert. Control the virus. Save lives”. Scotland, Wales, and NI retain the “Stay Home” slogan. Scotland also indicates its first major divergence in COVID-19 response with its policy aim of “Zero Covid”. The UK government changes the slogan again on 9 September to “Hands. Face. Space.” – indicating a further shift from a solidaristic call for action, to a simple mnemonic.
NHS Test and Trace System is announced for June 1 launch
Johnson promises a “world-beating” track and trace system by 1 June including 25,000 trackers dealing with 10,000 new cases/day. On 28 May, the new NHS Test and Trace System is unveiled, managed by Baroness Dido Harding and largely operated by private companies including Deloitte, Serco, Sitel, and Amazon, in parallel with Public Health England’s local health protection teams and local authorities. The system is launched without the digital contact tracing app, with a budget that reaches £12bn by October. Serco’s initial deal to supply contact tracers until 23 August was worth £108m with the possibility of rising to £410m if extended. Sitel, which operates the call centres, was initially paid £84m, increasing to £310m if extended. In its first week, 5,407 people with the virus are contacted, amid reports that contact tracers had not received sufficient training and often had nothing to do. Despite earlier hyping of the digital contact tracing app under development, Harding says that human contact tracing was the “bedrock” of the test and trace scheme, while the app is merely the “cherry on top of the cake”. Similarly Minister Lord Bethell says about app: “We are seeking to get something going for the winter, but it isn’t the priority for us at the moment”. On 10 August, the government announces that 6,000 out of 18,000 contact tracers employed by Serco and Sitel would be sacked. Following criticism of over-centralisation and disappointing results in tracing contacts, in early August, further contact tracing is devolved to local authority level. In October, it is discovered that details of around 16,000 positive cases had been accidentally deleted while test results were being aggregated by Public Health England to pass to NHS Test and Trace, due to the use of outdated Excel spreadsheets. By November, there were reports of the government in talks with data analytics firm Palantir to fix problems with the NHS Test and Trace system, which in November was estimated to reach only around 18% of every infected person’s contacts, while the government’s SAGE advisors estimate that of the contacts reached, only around 20% are likely to be fully compliant when asked to self-isolate (NHS Test and Trace puts this estimate at around 50%). This falls far short of government targets, with advisers saying that to be effective, 80% of people testing positive must be reached and their close contacts traced, and that 80% of these contacts should then be reached and asked to self-isolate.
UK publishes review of disparities in risks and outcomes of COVID-19
The review confirms that the risk of death from COVID-19 is higher for ethnic minorities, with people of Bangladeshi heritage dying at twice the rate of white Britons, while other Black, Asian and minority ethnic (BAME) groups having between 10% and 50% higher risk of death. The report is criticised by the British Medical Association and Labour leader Keir Starmer among others for delays to the publication of safeguarding advice (not made public for a further two weeks), which had been removed from the report before its publication, and for the lack of promised risk assessments for many BAME doctors. The reasons given for the delay by a government minister were revealed to be misleading, and it was later reported that the black health expert announced by Public Health England to be leading the inquiry had in fact not been in charge, adding further confusion. This takes place during the aftermath of the killing of George Floyd by US police on 25 May, and on 6 June, a Black Lives Matter protest involving thousands of people, is held in central London. On 13 June, a further Public Health England report including recommendations, which had not been made public by the government, is leaked, and argues that factors such as racism and social inequality may have contributed to increased risks of infection and death from COVID-19 among BAME communities.
UK government announces use of Apple/Google API instead of development of its own contract tracing app
The UK government finally announces that it has abandoned the development of its own centralised contract tracing app for a second app developed using the Apple/Google API. The total cost of the original app was around £10m, and was abandoned following heavy criticism relating to data protection and privacy, as well as technical limitations that made the app ineffective. Field tests on both versions of the app find that the first version registered about 75% of nearby Android devices, but just 4% of iPhones, while the Apple / Google version was more accurate, logging 99% of Android devices and iPhones, but had difficulty measuring the distance between users’ devices. Harding states that neither version is fit for purpose and that NHSX will work on creating an app that would “enable anyone with a smartphone to engage with every aspect of the NHS Test and Trace service”.
UK and devolved governments introduce various COVID measures
Throughout June through September, the UK and devolved governments introduce and tinker with a series of different COVID measures that creates a confusing picture of rules that politicians themselves struggle to explain. A new regime of regional lockdowns on a tier-based system appears ineffective at preventing a new wave of infections, and NHS Test and Trace is overwhelmed as virus levels rise back to similar levels seen in March. In September, tests for COVID become impossible to access due to bottlenecks in the testing system. By 21 September, government scientific advisory group SAGE argues that NHS Test and Trace is having only “a marginal impact on [COVID-19] transmission”. SAGE advice in September for a short lockdown during school half–term holidays is disregarded by Johnson, until case rates reach an estimated 100,000 per day at end of September, leading to a new month-long national lockdown in November.
Face masks becomes compulsory for shoppers
The UK government makes the wearing of face masks by shoppers in shops and supermarkets compulsory in England. Advocates such as Prof Trisha Greenhalgh have been advising since early in the pandemic for applying the precautionary principle that masks should be worn, but government support for mask-wearing has been cautious. Since mid-May, the government had advised people to wear face coverings in enclosed public spaces, and this was made compulsory on public transport in England and at NHS facilities across the UK since 15 June. The new requirement for masks in shops and supermarkets goes largely unenforced, as many businesses refuse to police the rule, and the police themselves lack the resources to do so at a national scale. Shop workers are exempt from the rule. Anti-mask conspiracy theories continue to circulate on social media, and sporadic anti-lockdown protests are also often anti-mask.
StopCOVID NI launched in Northern Ireland
The digital contact tracing app StopCOVID NI is launched in Northern Ireland – the first such app in the UK, and the first in the world to work across national borders, in the Republic of Ireland. Scotland launches the Protect Scotland app on 10 September. Finally, on the 24 September, the NHS COVID-19 app is launched for England and Wales, at a total cost of around £25m. None of the three apps are designed to be interoperable or work across national borders within the UK. The NHS COVID-19 app is downloaded more than 10 million times in the first three days, and around 20 million times in the first month – representing about 34% of the total population of England and Wales. The new app has several features beyond symptom checking and alerts, including a QR code check-in function, ability to book a free COVID test, and self-isolation countdown timer. The app is designed to complement the NHS Test and Trace programme but does not share personal data with the system. Over the coming weeks, a number of problems are identified in the media: incompatibility with older phone models, an inability to enter test results from NHS hospitals, Public Health England labs, or Office of National Statistics testing, confusing messages about potential exposures, incorrect self-isolation advice and notifications, and confusion about whether data would be shared with the police.
National Institute for Health Protection replaces Public Health England
The UK government announces that Public Health England will be replaced by the National Institute for Health Protection, a new agency created to deal with the threat of infectious diseases by combining Public Health England with the NHS Test and Trace operation, to be headed initially by Dido Harding (currently the head of NHS Test and Trace).
Anti-lockdown demonstration in central London
An anti-lockdown demonstration involving hundreds of people in central London is organised by Piers Corbyn (brother of former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn), who is fined for the event under COVID-19 legislation. This marks the beginning of a resurgence of similar protests against lockdowns and masks across the UK, particularly in London, which continue sporadically into November.
Japan
Japan confirms its first COVID-19 case
In the following two weeks, the central government passes a cabinet order classifying COVID-19 as a designated infectious disease under the Infectious Disease Law and a quarantinable infectious disease under the Quarantine Law, enabling the enforcement of compulsory hospitalization, restrictions on commerce, and inspections of people entering the country. Prime Minister Shinzo Abe establishes the Japan Novel Coronavirus Response Headquarters.
Diamond Princess cruise ship placed in quarantine
The Diamond Princess cruise ship, with 3,711 passengers and crew on board, is placed under quarantine in Yokohama for 14 days. This is the first encounter in Japan with a substantial infection cluster, and the measures taken to deal with it are widely seen as inadequate, as over 700 on board are ultimately infected with COVID-19. However, much is learned from epidemiologists about how the virus spreads. The government’s strategy subsequently focuses on preventing large-scale clusters, leading to the suspension of large gatherings, and the limiting of patients with minor symptoms from visiting medical facilities. Public health advice is clearly communicated to the public at an early stage, encouraging people to wear masks and avoid the “3Cs” (sanmitsu in Japanese): closed spaces, crowded places, and close-contact settings. The tiny amount of testing in Japan, by comparison to countries like South Korea or Germany, and the difficulty for most people to obtain a test, will remain a concern for many over the coming months. As of 30 April, 10,981 people have been tested in Tokyo, with just over 4,000 (36%) returned positive; official guidelines for doctors state that tests should only be recommended if the patient has pneumonia, suggesting hidden but widespread community transmission (by the end of May, the percentage of positive results will drop to below 1%). This is also part of the reason for the suspicion early in the pandemic that the Japanese government was suppressing the true number of COVID cases through lack of testing (even when capacity was available) and misrecording deaths as pneumonia, although no conclusive evidence has been presented for this accusation, and excess deaths figures show a reduction in deaths in 2020 compared with previous years. Public health experts such as Prof Kenji Shibuya urge the Japanese government to conduct more testing.
First COVID-19 emergency response package is passed
The first COVID-19 emergency response package is passed. Key measures include support for Japanese travellers abroad to return home, strengthening of immigration control, and loan support for SMEs. Travel restrictions are brought in through February and March, stranding abroad thousands of non-Japanese residents and workers who had temporarily left Japan before the pandemic struck. They will be unable to return to Japan until immigration restrictions are eased in September. A series of emergency packages and measures are passed in the coming months, providing huge economic stimuli and increasing hospital capacity.
PM Abe requests jishuku (“self-restraint”)
In a televised address on the national response to COVID‐19, PM Abe asks Japanese people to exercise jishuku (“self-restraint”) – avoiding leisure activities, fun family events, or vacations. Unlike almost every other country, the Japanese government has no power to impose punitive measures to compel people to follow its recommendations, and can only request people to do so voluntarily. The government also does not have the legal power to shut schools, but requests that they do so on the 2 March; at the time, this is an unpopular move, seen as an overreaction by some domestic and international observers.
Hospitals turning away ambulances with COVID-19 critical patients
News media reports that a growing number of hospitals are turning away ambulances carrying patients with critical cases of COVID-19: in March in Tokyo alone, over 931 emergency patients are reported to have been rejected by five or more hospitals or waited more than 20 minutes to find an emergency room; in April the figure jumped to 1,733. The Japanese government cannot compel most hospitals (many of which are run as private businesses) to accept these patients, and despite offering some additional funding to hospitals, hospital operators and members of the Tokyo Metropolitan government, which already had a difficult relationship with the central government before the pandemic, criticise them for not providing adequate financial support. Reports also grow of shortages of PPE and other medical equipment through April.
PM Abe’s approval ratings drop
Following a distinct lack of public appearances in February, Prime Minister Abe’s approval ratings slump to the high 30s – the lowest of his second term – and millions call for his resignation on Twitter. Tokyo Governor Yuriko Koike, on the other hand, wins praise for her clear communication during the pandemic, ultimately leading to her landslide reelection on July 5.
2020 Tokyo Olympic and Paralympic Games are postponed
The 2020 Tokyo Olympic and Paralympic Games are postponed for one year. Over the following week, official figures of COVID-19 infections in Tokyo jump, with the number of daily cases reported more than doubling (albeit from a low base), sparking accusations from former Japanese Prime Minister Yukio Hatoyama and others that the true number of cases had been suppressed while hope remained that the Games might still take place. The next day, Tokyo Governor Yuriko Koike – one of those accused of suppressing the infection figures – holds an emergency news conference, asking residents to stay at home over the coming weekend, and requesting a tighter level of jishuku (“self-restraint”). Although Koike, a former news presenter, is praised for her clear communication style, including her presentations in English aimed at foreign residents, the announcement also sparks panic buying across Tokyo as residents fear a possible lockdown. On 26 March, the central government sets up a special task force to combat the spread of the coronavirus, seen as a key measure towards declaring a state of emergency. The ability for the Prime Minister to declare a state of emergency due to COVID itself required a bill to be passed by the Japanese parliament, led by Economic Revitalization Minister Yasutoshi Nishimura, who becomes the minister in charge of Japan’s COVID-19 response.
First of four “national surveys for COVID-19 countermeasures” is conducted
The Ministry of Health, Labour, and Welfare conducts the first of four “national surveys for COVID-19 countermeasures” in collaboration with LINE, Japan’s most popular messaging/social media company with 83 million users (67% of the Japanese population). Approximately 30% of users (about 20% of the Japanese population) respond. This is seen as a quick way to gauge the approximate level of COVID–19 symptoms being experienced nationwide.
PM Abe announces distribution of cloth masks
PM Abe announces distribution of two washable cloth masks to every household in Japan, a measure dubbed “Abeno-mask”: a pun on Abe’s economic strategy nicknamed “Abenomics”. The plan is widely ridiculed with memes on social media, and its high cost and poor delivery criticised. Abe himself is the subject of frequent mockery for wearing one of these masks, which is smaller than standard surgical masks. Later in April, the government decides to pay every resident in Japan ¥100,000 (£715).
A state of emergency is declared in Tokyo and six prefectures
On 16 April, PM Abe extends it to the rest of the country for an indefinite period, although it is ultimately lifted for the whole country on 25 May. In the intervening weeks, people are asked to stay home during the key “Golden Week” holiday period, and again to practice jishuku (“self-restraint”). This is the closest that Japan comes to the kinds of national lockdowns seen in the UK and Europe. The government has no legal authority to shut private businesses or impose penalties on people who refuse to socially distance or wear masks, but its recommendations are followed by the overwhelming majority of citizens. Kentaro Iwata, the expert in infectious diseases who criticised the measures taken in dealing with the outbreak on the Diamond Princess cruise liner, condemns the government’s lack of clear messaging on the need to stay at home and maintain social distance.
A doctor’s tweet criticising the national infection data sharing system goes viral
The system often involves doctors handwriting an infection notification and faxing it to their local public health centre, which then enters the data into the National Epidemiological Surveillance of Infectious Diseases (NESID) System, which in turn collates the data for the prefectural and national governments. Minister Masaaki Taira, in charge of Japan’s information technology policy, promises to address the issue by creating a new system, HER-SYS (Health Center Real-time information-sharing System on COVID-19) to replace the manual system. HER-SYS is rapidly developed by a company called Persol Process & Technology under contract from the Ministry of Health, Labour, and Welfare, and is launched on 29 May. But the system cannot be used in many parts of the country due to local data protection laws; these areas continue to use the previous manual process, and the problems are only resolved in September following changes to the design of the system. On December 13, NHK reports that inputting large amounts of data into HER-SYS is placing so much of a burden on some medical institutions that they have returned to their previous practice of manually handwriting forms and faxing them. Contact tracing is conducted manually by over 25,000 staff spread across Japan’s 469 local health centres (hokenjo), who focus on identifying clusters and determine who should receive a test, drawing both admiration for thoroughness as well as concern that the system could be overwhelmed by a sudden surge of cases.
Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare announces recommendations for “new lifestyle”
The Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare announced recommendations for a “new lifestyle” (atarashii seikatsuyōshiki) – long-term changes to behaviour to be practiced even after the end of the state of emergency. These include previous advice about social distancing and mask wearing, but also seek to normalise a variety of further practical changes to everyday life, such as refraining from speaking on public transport, avoiding sitting side-by-side while eating meals, and exercising at home. These suggestions remain voluntary, as the government lacks the legal power to enforce them.
Google and Apple restrict contract tracing tool to one app per country
Also on May 4, Google and Apple announce that their contact tracing tool will be restricted to only one public health app per country, and must be built by public health authorities. The government, which has been investigating alternative approaches to building a digital contact tracing app, employs a team of Microsoft engineers to develop the COCOA (COntact-COnfirming Application) app using the Google/Apple framework. COCOA is launched on 19 June, but over the following weeks suffers from a series of bugs that prevent users from registering positive coronavirus test results obtained via HER-SYS, leading to confusion about its effectiveness. This is aggravated by the fact that HER-SYS is still not used nationwide until September. By October, 4 months after it has been launched, COCOA has only been downloaded by about 20% of the population. This falls far short of the 60% target identified by the government as the minimum uptake to have a material impact on transmission rates of COVID-19. In the meantime, several local areas have introduced their own QR contact tracing systems. For example in Osaka, restaurants, bars, and nightclubs can register their business data with the prefecture, which then sends them a QR code they can print out and display at their entrance. Customers can use their smartphones to scan the QR code and reach an online registration form where they can provide their email address.
Growing reports of jishuku keisatsu surface
From March onwards, there have been growing media reports and social media mention of so-called jishuku keisatsu (“self-restraint police”) – those who harass or publicly shame people online whom they believe have broken the government’s recommendation for “self-restraint” (e.g. by travelling outside their local area). Other terms include masuku keisatsu (“mask police”), coined for those who tell people off for not wearing masks on the street. Several people who are rumoured to have tested positive for COVID-19, as well as some medical staff working on the frontline and their children, are reported to face bullying and discrimination. There are reports of cars with out-of-prefecture license plates being egged, and stones are thrown at the home of a COVID patient in Mie. The phrase jishuku keisatsu – an inherent contradiction in terms that exposes jishuku’s underlying sense of social coercion rather than individual free choice – is eventually named one of the top buzzwords of 2020.
Abe lifts the state of emergency for the whole country
Abe claims victory over Japan’s second wave of infections
The New York Times reports him as saying: “By doing things in a uniquely Japanese way, we were able to almost completely end this wave of infection”, and suggesting that the “Japan model” offered a path out of the global pandemic.
Suicide numbers increase throughout summer and into autumn
The number of people committing suicide in Japan increases over the summer and into the autumn, and 2020 seems set to break a 10-year trend of continuous falls in national suicide numbers. The increase suggests a mental health crisis worsened by the pandemic and its knock-on impacts of rising unemployment, social isolation, and anxiety. By October 2020, there will be 2153 deaths in a single month – more than the total number of deaths caused by COVID to date, and the highest number since 2015. In the same month, the suicide rate for young people under the age of 20 reached its highest since records began in 1978.
Deputy PM and Finance Minister Taro Aso speaks about mindo (民度)
In an Upper House finance committee meeting, Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Taro Aso says: “I often got phone calls from (people) in other countries asking, ‘Do you guys have your own special medicine or something? I told these people, ‘Between your country and our country, mindo (the level of people) is different.’ And that made them speechless and quiet. Every time.” Mindo (民度) has the nuance of ethno-cultural superiority, and Aso, who has a well-established reputation as a right-wing provocateur, is denounced by opposition politicians.
Postponed Tokyo 2020 Games will proceed in simplified manner in 2021
The Tokyo 2020 Olympic Games organisers and International Olympic Committee agree that the postponed Games will proceed in a simplified manner in 2021.
Fugaku, world’s fastest supercomputer, is announced
RIKEN and Fujitsu announce the launch of the world’s fastest supercomputer, Fugaku. The computer is initially used to model aerosols droplets to understand the spread of COVID in enclosed spaces, with findings informing the height of office partitions to prevent COVID transmission, and the effectiveness of different types of face mask.
COVID test levels remain relatively low by international standards
For example, on July 20, 15,959 people in Japan received PCR tests, compared with 144,971 tests processed on the same day in the UK. From the end of July to the end of October, the level of PCR testing in Japan remained broadly constant at roughly 20,000 tests per day. This began to increase together with virus levels in November to around 40,000 tests per day. By November, by comparison, the UK was routinely processing over 300,000 tests per day.
Government announces “Go To” tourism campaign
The government launches the “Go To” tourism campaign, heavily subsidising domestic leisure travel. The campaign is widely criticised as misjudged in the midst of Japan’s second wave of infection, and likely to spread COVID-19 around the country at a time when travel should be avoided. The number of new cases spikes at the start of August before falling slightly in September, although cases remain high. In September, Go To is extended to subsidising visits to restaurants, and a further extension is planned to subsidise attending events by the end of the year. A third wave – the biggest to hit Japan so far – builds in November, with over 1,000 cases per day.
Prime Minister Abe announces his resignation on the grounds of ill health
Photo Credits:
UK:
UK Confirms Its First COVID-19 Case, COVID-19 Positive, Prasesh Shiwakoti (Lomash), https://unsplash.com/photos/moHiHqdmUYY
Herd Immunity And “Behavioural Fatigue,” People on Train, Corey Agopian, https://unsplash.com/photos/IEW2GMlvWM8
Hospitals Send Older Adults Back to Care Homes, Two Arms with Older Adult, Matthias Zomer, https://www.pexels.com/photo/action-adult-affection-eldery-339620/
Prime Minister Delivers TV Broadcast Instructing a Lockdown (Stay-At-Home-Order), Stay at Home, Protect the NHS, Save Lives, Nick Fewings, https://unsplash.com/photos/3jHA94zvLBk
COVID Symptom Study App Is Launched, Picture of App, COVID Symptom Study, https://covid.joinzoe.com/us-2
Independent Sage Is Formed, Picture of Logo, Independent Sage, https://www.independentsage.org
UK’s Public Health Messaging Changes, Slogan Picture, GOV.UK, https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/885652/2020-05-17_COVID-19_Press_Conference_Slides_-_to_be_published.pptx.pdf
NHS Test and Trace System Is Announced for June 1 Launch, NHS App, NCSC, https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/blog-post/nhs-test-and-trace-app-security-redux
UK Publishes Review of Disparities in Risks and Outcomes Of COVID-19, Social Contract Was Broken, Edward Howell, https://unsplash.com/photos/1rnv_eZZG3c
Anti-Lockdown Demonstration In Central London, Photo of Protestors, Ehimetalor Akhere Unuabona, https://unsplash.com/photos/ZJkzwzOS6fQ
Japan:
Hospitals Turning Away Ambulances With COVID-19 Critical Patients, Hospital Room, Arseny Togulev, https://unsplash.com/photos/DE6rYp1nAho
PM Abe Announces Distribution of Cloth Masks, Picture of Mask, Carina Sto, https://unsplash.com/photos/Iq3mzmjxsEk
Google And Apple Restrict Contract Tracing Tool to One App Per Country, Picture of App, Screenshot by Author, https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=jp.go.mhlw.covid19radar&hl=en_US&gl=US
Abe Claims Victory Over Japan’s Second Wave of Infections, People in Market, Matthew Tran, https://unsplash.com/photos/CO45mW7uMIU
Postponed Tokyo 2020 Games Will Proceed in Simplified Manner In 2021, Olympic Rings, Kyle Dias, https://unsplash.com/photos/ZIoi-47zV88
Fugaku, World’s Fastest Supercomputer, Is Announced, Picture of Fugaku, Wikimedia, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:FugakuSupercomputerSC19.jpg
Government Announces “Go To” Tourism Campaign, IHG Go To Campaign, IHG, https://www.ihg.com/content/gb/en/deals/hotel-offers/japan-go-to-travel
Prime Minister Abe Announces His Resignation On The Grounds Of Ill Health, Picture of PM Abe, Wikimedia, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Shinzo_Abe_answering_questions_on_new_imperial_era_name.jpg